Skip to main content
Podcast Episode 322: When Should I Rollover My 401k?
Created: September 15, 2023
Modified: September 14, 2023

Podcast Episode 322: When Should I Rollover My 401k?

We want to be as efficient as possible with our retirement accounts to give us the best chance to grow our money and provide the income we need for retirement. That’s why many people ask about rollovers and whether it makes sense to do that with their 401k. Let’s talk about who might and might not benefit from a rollover and the options you have for your old 401k accounts.

We brought on Matt Pastor, RICP®, who has been a financial advisor with Johnson Brunetti since 2017, to help us with this conversation. It’s a question we get asked a lot and a conversation we have with many of our clients.

It’s first important to know what happens at the age of 59 and a half. First, there’s no longer the 10% IRS penalty to remove money out of your 401k. And second, you are eligible for a service rollover, which means you can move money out of the 401k and into a traditional IRA while still maintaining your employment with that company.

With that said, this decision often comes when you’re moving jobs. The old 401k plan is often forgotten about and left untouched because you usually don’t need that money for many years. The primary benefit of using this rollover strategy is diversification. Moving your money from a 401K to an IRA broadens your investment horizon, giving you more options for investment. However, it’s essential to consider your unique situation.

Now, when you change jobs, you essentially have four options to choose from for your 401k. The first option you have is to do nothing and leave the money where it is in the 401k plan. The second option is to move the money from your old 401k into the new 401k plan with your new company. For the most part, you will be welcome to do that and it’s an option to help consolidate.

The third option is you can take a cash payment, which is something we don’t typically recommend because of the tax ramifications that come along with pulling all of that money out at once. And finally, you have the option to roll the money over into a traditional IRA, which gives you more access and flexibility with your money.  

The bottomline is you need to be getting some guidance with all of this. It’s not an easy decision and there are nuances for each situation, which isn’t something you’d be expected to know on your own. That’s when we’ll sit down and talk through those options with you to determine which is the best fit. You can also take advantage of our ultimate 401k Guide by reaching out and letting us know you’re interested.

Here’s what you can expect to learn in this episode:

• The different qualifying events that usually make people consider the rollover.

• Why would you want to do a rollover in the first place?

• Assuming you’re eligible, why wouldn’t you want to roll the money over?

• What option do you have if you want to retire before 59 and a half if you don’t want to move all the money out of your 401k.

• The fear or apprehension that comes with moving money out of a 401k.

Information presented here is considered current as of the created date. Over time, some information presented may become stale. We recommend you consult with your Financial Professional before making any changes based on information contained here.

Johnson Brunetti is a marketing name for the businesses of JB Capital and JN Financial.
Investment Advisory Services offered through JB Capital, LLC. Insurance Products offered through JN Financial, LLC.
The guarantees provided by any type of insurance contract are based on the claims-paying ability of the insurance company.

Resources by Topic

Subscribe to Our YouTube Channel

Share

Related Resources

  • Podcast Episode 448: How Often Should I Check My Investment Portfolio?

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. A 2025 survey found that 40% of people with retirement savings check their investment performance at least once per month, while 26%…
  • Podcast Episode 447: 5 Ways to Boost Your Financial IQ

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. Financial decisions don’t exist in a vacuum, and the cost of getting them wrong can quietly build up over time. According to the Nat…
  • Podcast Episode 446: I’m 62 with $800K: How Can I Lower Taxes in Retirement?

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. An important question as you near retirement with a solid nest egg is not how much you saved, but how much you’ll keep. If most of y…
  • Podcast Episode 445: Tracking Down a Lost 401(k)

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. It may sound hard to believe, but in 2023, Americans lost track of nearly 30 million 401(k) accounts, amounting to roughly $1.65 tri…
  • Podcast Episode 444: Why Women Investors Outperform Men

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. Could women have a behavioral advantage in investing? A recent Fidelity study found that women investors tend to achieve positive ret…
  • Podcast Episode 443: How Can I Increase My Social Security Benefit?

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. Social Security is one of the biggest financial decisions you’ll ever make. But knowing when to file for benefits is rarely as simple…
  • Podcast Episode 442: What is the Rule of 55?

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. If you’re considering early retirement, you may want to take advantage of the Rule of 55. This lesser-known provision allows for pena…
  • Podcast Episode 441: 5 Money Habits to Break

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. A recent Intuit Credit Karma study found that 63% of Americans want to build healthier financial habits in 2026. Among the top hab…
  • Podcast Episode 440: How to Train Your Finances Like an Olympic Athlete

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. To become an Olympian, you need more than just natural talent. Such training involves discipline, practice, and a focused mindset. Th…
  • Podcast Episode 439: What’s Your Retirement Relationship Status?

    Prefer to watch? Click here to watch and listen on YouTube. Are you taking your relationship with retirement day by day, hoping things work out? Or are you in a committed, long-term relationshi…
    Back to top
    • Laura H.
      Laura H. is a client of Johnson Brunetti and received no compensation for their statement.

      “Your corporate values and mission have stayed constant which we’d say is the primary reason we are so satisfied. We believe that mission should never change.”

      Testimonials received in response to Johnson Brunetti survey conducted in 2024.  Please click here for a description of the survey and the overall results. 

    • John L.
      John L. is a client of Johnson Brunetti and received no compensation for his statement.

      “We are extremely please with J&B. Referring back to our one word, Family, we trust your firm, advisors, and services as we would a member of the Family. Thank you for everything!”

      Testimonials received in response to Johnson Brunetti survey conducted in 2024.  Please click here for a description of the survey and the overall results. 

    • Joe D.
      Joe D. is a client of Johnson Brunetti and received no compensation for his statement.

      “Your model is working well, continue to keep your focus on your clients. The podcasts are an effective way of communicating information and real life stories. Your business is supporting your clients’ many different real life stories.”

      Testimonials received in response to Johnson Brunetti survey conducted in 2024.  Please click here for a description of the survey and the overall results. 

    • Jackie L.
      Jackie L. is a client of Johnson Brunetti and received no compensation for her statement.

      “I love how everyone in the company makes us feel. Like we are one big happy family. I wouldn’t change anything! “

      Testimonials received in response to Johnson Brunetti survey conducted in 2024.  Please click here for a description of the survey and the overall results.

    • Christine Q.
      Christine Q. is a client of Johnson Brunetti and received no compensation for her statement.

      “Your services are exemplary and greatly appreciated by my husband and myself to live out our retirement years feeling safe and secure. Thank you!”

      Testimonials received in response to Johnson Brunetti survey conducted in 2024.  Please click here for a description of the survey and the overall results. 

    • Barbara S.
      Barbara S. is a client of Johnson Brunetti and received no compensation for her statement.

      “We are very happy with Johnson Brunetti. It has really taken a load off our shoulders. Thank you.”

      Testimonials received in response to Johnson Brunetti survey conducted in 2024.  Please click here for a description of the survey and the overall results. 

      Our Locations
      Johnson Brunetti
      Welcome to Our New Website!
      Everything was designed with you in mind, making our retirement planning resources more easily accessible to you.
      Check out your new resource center, where everything can be organized by article type or topic
      Are you ready to speak with a financial advisor?
      Skip to content