Skip to main content
Created: April 18, 2022
Modified: January 15, 2025

Episode 68: Is It Better to Have a 401(k) or an IRA?

Have your question answered on the Money Wisdom Question Series!

Today we’re here to answer your question, “Is It Better to Have a 401(k) or an IRA?”

If you’re asking this question, it means that you’ve saved to some degree for retirement, and we applaud that. We love people that save for retirement. Generally, a 401(k) is sponsored by an employer, whereas an IRA is individually set up by individuals. Most often when people leave an employer or ultimately retire, they roll over their retirement accounts from a 401(k) to an IRA account.

Reasons Why People May Keep Their 401(k)

Some of these reasons could be based on age. You’re probably familiar with some of the rules in regards to accessing money younger than 59 and 1/2, and that there are penalties if you do that. There are some times when you can access money in a 401(k) younger than 59 and 1/2 and avoid that penalty. In those circumstances, it’s better to leave that money in the 401(k) rather than roll it over to an IRA.

You’re also probably familiar that at age 72 people are generally required to start taking money out of retirement accounts, but in many plans, most plans. If you’re still working for the employer age 72 and beyond, you do not have to take money out of the 401(k). Not all, but most of them. You’d want to check with your employer’s plan.

There could be other reasons to leave money in a 401(k). Let’s say your 401(k) has such a unique investment inside of it, and it’s so good that you cannot access that type of investment outside of that 401(k). Well, maybe it makes sense to keep some or all of that money there, so you can continue to utilize that investment.

Maybe you have highly appreciated company stock inside of the 401(k), and there could be reasons to leave some of that money there, so you can potentially utilize some special tax benefits later on down the road.

Why Some People Consider an IRA Rollover

Now all these reasons being said, most people when they leave an employer or retire roll money from the 401(k) into a Roth IRA at that point. Normally, the reason why they do this is to have more control and flexibility over that money, and primarily to be able to access a wide array of investments.

Usually, 401(k)’s are rather limited in the options that they have available, whereas IRAs can be invested really in anything under the sun from an investment standpoint. People are usually rolling that money out to an IRA so they can get more choice from an investment standpoint, more choice in terms of safe types of options that might be available to them outside of the 401(k), and even risk-based types of options that are available to you outside of the 401(k).

Takeaways

It’s important to take a look at your overall strategy for retirement before making these kinds of decisions. Be sure to seek professional guidance.

Thanks for joining me and I hope you found this information helpful!

Download Now

The Ultimate 401(k) Guide

Learn the 5 decisions you need to make regarding your 401(k) in this book by Eric Hogarth, CFP®. He’ll help guide you through the many options you have with your 401(k) and to provide the clarity you need to help you make the important decisions that will provide the foundation for you and your family’s financial future.

Information presented in our podcasts is considered current as of the created date. Over time, some information presented may become stale. We recommend you consult with your Financial Professional before making any changes based on information contained here.

Johnson Brunetti is a marketing name for the businesses of JB Capital and JN Financial.

Investment Advisory Services offered through JB Capital, LLC. Insurance Products offered through JN Financial, LLC.
The guarantees provided by any type of insurance contract are based on the claims-paying ability of the insurance company.

Resources by Topic

The Ultimate 401(k) Guide

Share

Related Resources

  • How Do I Get Out of Debt Fast?

    Most people with debt want to get out of it quickly and efficiently. To do that, you first need a clear understanding of your financial situation. Second, you need a clear, actionable plan. In …
  • Why Do I Need to Account for Inflation in Retirement?

    Today’s question is: What is inflation and why is it important to account for in my retirement plan? Inflation is the rising cost of goods over time. Meaning, it will cost you more money next year…
  • How Does a Tax Return Work?

    As tax season concludes, it’s a good time to refresh your tax knowledge. In this week’s Money Wisdom Question Series, Ian Fergusson, RICP® discusses how filing your taxes works and why it’s essen…
  • What Is a Fiduciary?

    When it comes to managing your money, trust is everything. That’s why today’s question is one of the most common and important ones we receive: What is a fiduciary? In this week’s Money Wisdom …
  • Can I Get ‘Out’ of a Fixed-Rate Vehicle?

    When you lock into a fixed-rate vehicle like a CD, fixed annuity, or fixed-indexed annuity, you’re committed to a specific interest rate for a set period. But what happens when after a few years, …
  • Are My Social Security Benefits Taxable?

    If your total combined income exceeds certain thresholds, up to 85% of your Social Security benefits may be taxable. Understanding how Social Security is taxed can help you make informed decisions…
  • What is the Social Security Fairness Act?

    You may have heard about the Social Security Fairness Act, which was signed into law on January 5, 2025. But what is it and who does it help? In this week’s Money Wisdom Question Series, Ian Fe…
  • How Can I Transition My Business Value into Money I Can Use?

    Today’s question is a crucial topic for many of our clients who are business owners or have significant assets tied up in a business: How can I convert the value of my business into income for my …
  • How Will My Retirement Account Withdrawals Affect My Taxes?

    Retirement income planning requires thoughtful decision-making, especially when it comes to minimizing the amount you’ll pay in taxes. In this week’s Money Wisdom Question Series, join Jake Dos…
  • What Are Some Unexpected Retirement Expenses to Look Out For?

    Today’s question is one we help our clients navigate all the time: What expenses might I be responsible for as I enter retirement? Nicholas J. Colantuono, CFP® joins this week’s Money Wisdom Qu…
    Back to top
    Our Locations
    Johnson Brunetti
    Welcome to Our New Website!
    Everything was designed with you in mind, making our retirement planning resources more easily accessible to you.
    Check out your new resource center, where everything can be organized by article type or topic
    Are you ready to speak with a financial advisor?
    Skip to content